Welcome to our opinion series. This month’s writer is Karen English, Director of International Procurement and Trade at NZGP
I read a headline that New Zealand had slipped to fourth place in the Transparency International Corruption Perception Index and I was horrified!
I wasn’t totally surprised because we slipped to third place in the 2023 survey, the first time since 2012 that we weren’t number one or number two.
I pay attention to these surveys as they measure among other things, New Zealand’s government procurement policy. Maybe I just love to hold the moral high ground, maybe I see the reputation of a country as a big deal, or maybe commentary on the performance of the public service is commentary on me, you and the work we do.
I would probably be more sanguine about this score if it was a singular survey, but I read another article that pointed out New Zealand’s drop across a number of international indices. In fact, I input into the World Bank B-READY Survey, formerly Ease of Doing Business survey, where we used to rank at or near the top and was taken aback by the results. The B-Ready survey is complicated, and I don’t pretend that I’m knowledgeable in deciphering the results. It shows performance across defined topics and pillars, rather than rolling up the data into an overall score. Procurement features in the “competition” topic and we scored 9 out of 33 under the heading “bidding for public contracts”! Our overall competition score is lower than Georgia and Rwanda.
It’s quite a mission to try to dig into the various indicators that make up the score. I know the score on these surveys is contingent on what is being counted towards a good score, where the data has come from and what is being used to validate the data. The B-Ready survey used various data sources, but I do wonder if part of the problem is the quality of New Zealand’s procurement data. I personally complete many international surveys on government procurement and I frequently run across questions where I have to respond “this information is not centrally collected”.
So, all is well, right? We are still ok. We just can’t prove it. But shouldn’t we be able to? In this age where data rules, I fear procurement’s contribution to these surveys will see New Zealand’s rankings continue to slide.
What can or are we doing about our data performance and why should we care? Musings on that next time.